Martha's Old Mexico Restaurant
Inside Martha's Old Mexico Restaurant
Martha's Old Mexico Restaurant sits comfortably on Sebastopol’s Main Street, offering a full-service Mexican dining experience that balances homey comfort with a touch of local charm. This spot is best suited for those who appreciate classic Latin American flavors served in a setting that feels both inviting and thoughtfully curated.
Inside, diners will notice the unique tables and chairs — with playful fruit-themed options that kids seem to love — while the real draw during warmer months is the back patio. This outdoor space, nestled among greenery and ambient lighting, creates a peaceful retreat from downtown bustle. It’s a natural choice for relaxed lunches or romantically lit dinners, where gentle heaters extend the season beyond summer.
The menu highlights traditional dishes with a twist. Standouts like the Huevos Rancheros and Seafood Relleños reflect hearty, authentic roots, while salads with fajita or pork options bring a fresh, lighter balance. Large portions, such as the veggie burrito or the carne asada Colima style, satisfy bigger appetites without feeling over-serving. Meals here often come paired with three varieties of fresh salsas, complemented by generous sides like hot beans, which add an unexpected layer of warmth to the meal.
Drink options lean into classic Mexican favorites, with reasonable prices on sangria, margaritas, and the house-special “MarthaRita,” making the restaurant a solid pick for casual celebrations or unwinding after a day exploring the North Bay.
Service is straightforward and attentive, matching the comfortable atmosphere rather than a formal dining room experience. Frequent diners seem to appreciate the steady quality and the way the restaurant blends traditional Mexican recipes with Sebastopol's relaxed vibe.
Martha’s Old Mexico Restaurant fits well for families, couples looking for a low-key date night, or groups craving solid, flavorful Mexican fare paired with a scenic outdoor spot. Midday to early evening visits, especially in pleasant weather, make the most of the back patio’s quiet charm. For locals and visitors alike, it offers a taste of Mexico with a distinctly Sonoma County sensibility.
Highlights & Local Essentials
Find It on the Map
What Locals & Travelers Say
286 Reviews
08 Jan 2026
05 Jan 2026
26 Dec 2025
28 Nov 2025
26 Nov 2025
18 Oct 2025
08 Oct 2025
More Local Spots to Explore
Celsius Coffee Nilai
Barista Kurunegala 2 ( Dambulla Road)
Chiang Rai Thai Kitchen (Northyork)
Flannerys Bar
Demli Cafe Lounge
Join the Martha's Old Mexico Restaurant Newsletter
Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.